Skip to main content
Business Environment Reform banner

Business Environment Reform

Results and Indicators for Development
Jobs & Growth

Results and Indicators

Result Indicators
Impact
Increased sustainable inclusive economic
growth with improved livelihoods and
decent employments (more and better jobs)
Proportion of youth (aged 15-24 years) not in education, employment or training ( SDG 8.6.1)
(Percentage)
Data Source:

United Nations Statistics

Additional Information

Related to SDG 8.6.1

Domestic material consumption, domestic material consumption per capita, and domestic material consumption by GDP ( SDG 12.2.2)
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

United Nations Statics - Open SDG Data Hub

Additional Information

Related to SDG 12.2.2

Growth rates of household expenditure or income per capita among the bottom 40 per cent of the population and the total population (SDG 10.1.1)
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

United Nations Statics - Open SDG Data Hub

Additional Information

Related to SDG 10.1.1

Export of goods and services as percentage of GDP (SDG 1.15) (OPSYS core indicator)
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:
Result Indicators
Specific Objective - Outcome
Increased and diversified trade
in goods and services
Volume and value of intra-regional trade in [X] in supported region
(Tonnes/MWh/etc**, Currency)
Data Source:

WTO and regional trade organisations
 

Additional Information

[X] – please specify for your intervention. Could be goods, services, electricity, etc.
** exact unit will depend on the commodities/services chosen

Value of exports/ Export as % of GDP
(Currency or Percentage)
Data Source:

World Bank

Export concentration index (OPSYS core indicator)
(Score)
Data Source:

UNCTAD



 

Additional Information

Concentration index, also named Herfindahl-Hirschmann Index (Product HHI), is a measure of the degree of product concentration.

The index is valued between 0 and 1, where closer to 1 indicates a country's exports or imports are highly concentrated on a few products.

Result Indicators
Specific Objective - Outcome
Increased private inclusive &
sustainable investment
(domestic and foreign)
Domestic credit to private sector (% of GPD) (OPSYS core indicator)
(Percentage)
Data Source:
Foreign direct investment net inflows as percent of GDP
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

World Bank
UNCTAD

Additional Information

Estimates might vary between different sources due methodological differences, so please use one source (and hence estimation methodology) for programme monitoring.

Gross fixed capital formation (% of GDP)
(Percentage)
Data Source:

World Bank

Result Indicators
Specific Objective - Outcome
Increased private sector engagement
and leverage
Net taxes and fees paid to government by supported businesses or intermediaries
(Currency)
Data Source:

EU intervention monitoring and reporting systems (Progress and final reports for the EU-funded intervention; EU-funded feasibility or appraisal reports ; Baseline and endline studies conducted and budgeted by the EU-funded intervention )

Additional Information

Periodic surveys (at least annual) as part of intervention M&E

Number of new private sector firms investing in sector/value chain [X]
(Number of firms)
Data Source:

Expert analysis of sector and/or value chain
 

Additional Information

sector/value chain [X] – to be defined, which is most relevant to programme.
 
Compare pre and post programme numbers to get the number of new firms

Number and value of Private Partnership in Infrastructure
(Number and Currency)
Data Source:

World bank

Additional Information

The Private Participation in Infrastructure (PPI) Project Database has data on over 6,400 infrastructure projects in 139 low- and middle-income countries. The database is the leading source of PPI trends in the developing world, covering projects in the energy, telecommunications, transport, and water and sewerage sectors. Projects include management or lease contracts, concessions, greenfield projects, and divestitures.

Levels of private co-financing
(Currency (€, $ , local currency))
Data Source:

Intervention M&E system

Additional Information

Do not include financing from bilateral, multilateral or DFIs.
At HQ, may need to disaggregate by EIP vs other programmes and projects.

Result Indicators
Specific Objective - Outcome
Reduced transaction time and costs associated with compliance with business procedures
Land transfer cost as a percentage of property value? taken from the ICR Diagnostic Toolkit (2018)
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

At least two surveys of experts as part of intervention M&E system

Percentage of enterprise owners and managers who rate the advice and services provided by the tax office as excellent or very good, disaggregated by enterprise size, sector and sex of enterprise owner/manager
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

Survey of enterprise owners/managers - before and after programme

Additional Information

Please adapt the indicator according to the question you have

Percentage of business owners and managers who perceptive government regulation as very or fairly transparent disaggregated by sex of business owner/manager
(Percentage (%))
Data Source:

Enterprise perception survey: pre- and post-reforms as part of intervention M&E

Additional Information

Please adapt the indicator according to the question you have

Actual number of days to comply with business regulations [or regulation X], disaggregated by type of firm, sex of head of firm
(Number)
Data Source:

Firm surveys as part of the intervention M&E (at least twice within the lifetime of the programme

Additional Information

Focus on actual times need to comply with regulations rather than the published times from official documentation and/or procedures.
Business regulation can refer to all business regulations or specific reforms that the intervention has supported, e.g. days to obtain an operating license/construction related permit, etc. If the latter, then you need to specific in the indicator, e.g. actual number of days to comply with tax regulation, etc.

Burden of government regulation perceptions index
(Score)
Data Source:

WFE Global competitiveness index – sub indicator

Additional Information

Measures business executives' perceptions of their country's government regulation burden: question asked is "In your country, how burdensome is it for businesses to comply with governmental administrative requirements (e.g., permits, regulations, reporting)? [1 = extremely burdensome; 7 = not burdensome at all] "
Note this is only perceptions, and less likely to capture views of smallholder or micro business's opinions.

World Bank's Overall Ease of Doing Business ranking and/or distance to the frontier score (OPSYS core indicator)
(Number)
Additional Information

This would normally be a national level or a high level outcome indicators or even may also be used at impact level for some programmes.

World Bank's Ease of Doing Business Ranking from 1 to 190, with 1 being the top ranking.

Ease of Doing Business Distance to Frontier Score, from 0 to 100  (higher the score means closer to the frontier)

Improvement of the business environment, measured as the "Distance to frontier indicators":

  • The distance to frontier score benchmarks economies with respect to regulatory best practice
  • The ranking compares economies with one another based on the aggregate score. So the rank could decrease even if the frontier score has increased.

It's more meaningful to monitor the score of the topic and/or at sub-national level that is most relevant to the project rather than looking at overall country score.

Please note that some elements of the Doing Business surveys are largely based on measurements of the regulations rather than firm experience on the ground. So if possible programmes should also monitor the realities on the ground through additional enterprise surveys etc.